Player Comparison
Side by side on performance, context, cost and risk. Differences are explained — no single 'better player' verdict.
| Bernardo Silva remove | John McGinn remove | |
|---|---|---|
| Age | 31 | 31 |
| Position | Attacking midfielder | Right midfielder |
| Club · league | Manchester City · Premier League | Aston Villa · Premier League |
| League strength | 1.30 | 1.30 |
| Team strength (Elo) | 1809 | 1721 |
| League minutes | 2888 (84%) | 2158 (63%) |
| G+A per 90 (raw) | 0.19 | 0.42 |
| G+A per 90 (context-adjusted) | 0.17 | 0.27 |
| Passing / defending / progression | Data unavailable | Data unavailable |
| Performance percentile | 99 | 98 |
| Market value | €22.0M | €13.0M |
| Estimated acquisition | €8.6M – €22.3M | €6.9M – €13.8M |
| Model value | €25.4M – €47.6M | €19.3M – €35.9M |
| Projected value (24m) | €4.4M – €9.9M | €2.7M – €6.7M |
| Bargain Index | 0/100 | 0/100 |
| Development | Low | Low |
| Breakout probability | n/a (age > 23) | n/a (age > 23) |
| Risk | Low | Low |
| Data confidence | Medium | Medium |
| Value picture | Estimated acquisition€8.6M – €22.3M Model value (performance-implied)€25.4M – €47.6M Projected value (24 months)€4.4M – €9.9M Dashed line: current market value (€22.0M). Bars are 20–80% model ranges; tick = median. | Estimated acquisition€6.9M – €13.8M Model value (performance-implied)€19.3M – €35.9M Projected value (24 months)€2.7M – €6.7M Dashed line: current market value (€13.0M). Bars are 20–80% model ranges; tick = median. |
What separates Bernardo Silva and John McGinn
- McGinn has higher context-adjusted goal contributions (0.27 vs 0.17 per 90).
- Silva was used far more by the club (84% of minutes vs 63%).
- McGinn is estimated to cost far less (€9.8M vs €15.8M mid-estimate).